• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Science & Technology
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech

Building An Influential Policy Making Institution

January 6, 2017
Mum couple held in Kolkata for smuggling gold

Mum couple held in Kolkata for smuggling gold

December 11, 2019
Thane: Chemicals’ discharge into drain irks all

Thane: Chemicals’ discharge into drain irks all

December 11, 2019
After Months Of Deadlock, Israel Heads To Third Election In A Year

After Months Of Deadlock, Israel Heads To Third Election In A Year

December 11, 2019
Muslim Organisation To Challenge Citizenship Bill In Supreme Court

Muslim Organisation To Challenge Citizenship Bill In Supreme Court

December 11, 2019
Muslim Organisation To Challenge Citizenship Bill In Supreme Court

Muslim Organisation To Challenge Citizenship Bill In Supreme Court

December 11, 2019
Tribal Outfits In Tripura Call Off Protests Against Citizenship Bill

Tribal Outfits In Tripura Call Off Protests Against Citizenship Bill

December 11, 2019
Tribal Outfits In Tripura Call Off Protests Against Citizenship Bill

Tribal Outfits In Tripura Call Off Protests Against Citizenship Bill

December 11, 2019
Siddaramaiah Undergoes Angioplasty, Family Says Health Stable

Siddaramaiah Undergoes Angioplasty, Family Says Health Stable

December 11, 2019
Pics: Kriti enjoys her vacation in Switzerland

Pics: Kriti enjoys her vacation in Switzerland

December 11, 2019

Fans call Janhvi Kapoor 'the next Sridevi'

December 11, 2019
Mandira Bedi's 'Patloon kaise bhooley' pic

Mandira Bedi's 'Patloon kaise bhooley' pic

December 11, 2019
Controversial scene deleted from 'Panipat'

Controversial scene deleted from 'Panipat'

December 11, 2019
Thursday, December 12, 2019
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Editor In Chief SANTOSH BHARTIYA
Chauthi Duniya(Eng)
No Result
View All Result
  • Nation
    new frank

    Civic education can enhance democracy in India

    Shujaat Bukhari: An epitome of courage and objectivity

    Shujaat Bukhari: An epitome of courage and objectivity

    Bhaiyyu Ji’s Death: Suicide or Murder

    Bhaiyyu Ji’s Death: Suicide or Murder

    Samajwadi Party National Executive:  Azam Khan takes a dig at Ram Gopal Yadav and Naresh Agarwal

    Samajwadi Party National Executive: Azam Khan takes a dig at Ram Gopal Yadav and Naresh Agarwal

    NGT’s Ban on  Protest at Jantar Mantar: A Blow to Democracy

    NGT’s Ban on Protest at Jantar Mantar: A Blow to Democracy

    GST Pushes Modi Government on Back Foot:  Gujarat, Himachal Assembly Election Soften Government’s Stand On Gst

    GST Pushes Modi Government on Back Foot: Gujarat, Himachal Assembly Election Soften Government’s Stand On Gst

    Mohammad Ahsan Ahsan: The man behind the scene

    Mohammad Ahsan Ahsan: The man behind the scene

    Rohit-Shnaker

    Rohit Shekhar vs. Narayan Dutt Tiwari: DNA Test, Court’s Decision and the question of patrimonial rights?

    GOdha

    Godda: Adani Power Plant

    EVM

    EC to demonstrate VVPAT, hoping to put EVM row at rest

    Trending Tags

    • World
      Fleeing Rohingya on trial in Myanmar for "illegal travel"

      Fleeing Rohingya on trial in Myanmar for "illegal travel"

      Climate pledges 'misleading', Greta tells UN meet

      Climate pledges 'misleading', Greta tells UN meet

      German army to get military rabbis again after 100 years

      German army to get military rabbis again after 100 years

      UK polls: PM Boris Johnson holds on to lead but hung Parliament within margin

      UK polls: PM Boris Johnson holds on to lead but hung Parliament within margin

      Charge of Rohingya genocide is 'misleading': Myanmar's Suu Kyi to UN top court

      Charge of Rohingya genocide is 'misleading': Myanmar's Suu Kyi to UN top court

      UK polls: PM Boris Johnson holds on to lead but hung Parliament within margin

      UK polls: PM Boris Johnson holds on to lead but hung Parliament within margin

      Pak govt to impose curbs on media coverage of convicts and absconders

      Pak govt to impose curbs on media coverage of convicts and absconders

      China imprisoned more journalists than any other country in 2019: Watchdog

      China imprisoned more journalists than any other country in 2019: Watchdog

      Bougainville votes for independence from Papua New Guinea

      Bougainville votes for independence from Papua New Guinea

      Trending Tags

      • Economy
        We give utmost importance to all complaints: Sebi

        We give utmost importance to all complaints: Sebi

        Govt eases lending rules for weak shadow banks

        Chinese city turns into ghost town after Samsung shifts ops

        Chinese city turns into ghost town after Samsung shifts ops

        21,467 Indian websites hacked in 2019 till October

        21,467 Indian websites hacked in 2019 till October

        Why GST rates on various items may go up

        Why GST rates on various items may go up

        Saudi Aramco shares open 10% above IPO price

        AI in class: Is it reducing human interaction?

        AI in class: Is it reducing human interaction?

        Govt to protect buyers of cos facing insolvency

        Govt to protect buyers of cos facing insolvency

        Air India seeks guarantee to raise Rs 2.4k-cr loan

        Trending Tags

        • Sports
          Big sports events today

          Big sports events today

          Napoli name Gattuso as coach to replace Ancelotti

          Napoli name Gattuso as coach to replace Ancelotti

          3rd T20I: Batsmen dazzle as India clinch series with 67-run win against West Indies

          3rd T20I: Batsmen dazzle as India clinch series with 67-run win against West Indies

          After two years, I feel I have matured a lot: Manu Bhaker

          After two years, I feel I have matured a lot: Manu Bhaker

          BWF Tour Finals: Sindhu loses to Yamaguchi in Group 'A' match

          BWF Tour Finals: Sindhu loses to Yamaguchi in Group 'A' match

          Virat Kohli first Indian to score 1000 T20I runs on home soil

          Virat Kohli first Indian to score 1000 T20I runs on home soil

          Kiren Rijiju announces cash rewards for SAG medallists

          Kiren Rijiju announces cash rewards for SAG medallists

          South Africa appoint Graeme Smith acting director of cricket

          South Africa appoint Graeme Smith acting director of cricket

          Rohit Sharma becomes first Indian to hit 400 international sixes

          Trending Tags

          • Entertainment
            Pics: Kriti enjoys her vacation in Switzerland

            Pics: Kriti enjoys her vacation in Switzerland

            Fans call Janhvi Kapoor 'the next Sridevi'

            Mandira Bedi's 'Patloon kaise bhooley' pic

            Mandira Bedi's 'Patloon kaise bhooley' pic

            Controversial scene deleted from 'Panipat'

            Controversial scene deleted from 'Panipat'

            Read: 'Kabir Singh' beats 'Avengers: Endgame'

            Read: 'Kabir Singh' beats 'Avengers: Endgame'

            Arbaaz on rumours around Salman's marriage

            Arbaaz on rumours around Salman's marriage

            Ranbir and Alia pose for pics with a fan

            Ranbir and Alia pose for pics with a fan

            Read: Arbaaz and Giorgia to get married soon?

            Read: Arbaaz and Giorgia to get married soon?

            Alia praises 'Chhapaak' trailer and more

            CAB: Richa on the tense situation in Assam

            CAB: Richa on the tense situation in Assam

            Trending Tags

            • Lifestyle

              How old do you need to be to buy condoms in India?

              Indian Nobel Prize winner wore a dhoti at the ceremony

              4 daily habits that can give you acne

              4 daily habits that can give you acne

              4 daily habits that can give you acne

              4 daily habits that can give you acne

              Why many relationships end during Christmas

              Why many relationships end during Christmas

              All you need to know about the Keto 2.0

              4 myths about metabolism you should stop believing!

              Madhuri Dixit's nude sari is gorgeous to look at!

              Madhuri Dixit's nude sari is gorgeous to look at!

              8 easy tips to control your anger

              Sania Mirza's sister's Mehendi outfit is GORGEOUS

              Trending Tags

              • Golden Globes
              • Mr. Robot
              • MotoGP 2017
              • Climate Change
              • Flat Earth
            • Tech

              Apple iPhone 7, iPhone 7 Plus price details revealed, goes up to Rs 92,000

              Apple iPhone 7, iPhone 7 Plus price details revealed, goes up to Rs 92,000

              Apple iPhone 7, iPhone 7 Plus price details revealed, goes up to Rs 92,000

              Apple slashes prices of iPhone 6s and iPhone 6s Plus by up to Rs 22,000

              Apple slashes prices of iPhone 6s and iPhone 6s Plus by up to Rs 22,000

              Apple slashes prices of iPhone 6s and iPhone 6s Plus by up to Rs 22,000

              WhatsApp privacy policy challenged in Delhi High Court: 5 things to know

              WhatsApp privacy policy challenged in Delhi High Court: 5 things to know

              Is Car Technology Creating Stupid Drivers

              LG G Flex2 smartphone offers a self-repairing body

              ASUS ZenFone 2 delivers performance in a slim form factor

              The Basis Peak fitness and sleep tracker can help you form better habits

              Trending Tags

              • Flat Earth
              • Sillicon Valley
              • Mr. Robot
              • MotoGP 2017
              • Golden Globes
              • Future of News
            Chauthi Duniya(Eng)
            No Result
            View All Result
            Home Uncategorized

            Building An Influential Policy Making Institution

            by admin
            January 6, 2017
            in Uncategorized
            5 min read
            Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

            Areformed Planning Commission should reflect the diversity of Indian debate, says Suman Bery… The successor body should concentrate on three principal roles: agenda setting; synthesis of important research results in chosen areas from whatever sources; and convening power to stimulate public and political discussion on key long-term issues…

            RelatedPosts

            Mum couple held in Kolkata for smuggling gold

            Thane: Chemicals’ discharge into drain irks all

            After Months Of Deadlock, Israel Heads To Third Election In A Year

            Muslim Organisation To Challenge Citizenship Bill In Supreme Court


            building-an-influential-polI was privileged to be the director-general of the National Council of Applied Economic Research in New Delhi when that distinguished organisation celebrated its golden jubilee in 2006. At that time, I searched for documentation on how the institution came into existence and came across an essay prepared by Peter Geithner, the deputy head of the Ford Foundation in Delhi in the 1950s. (1) The Ford Foundation had recently established its first overseas office in New Delhi, and its head, Douglas Ensminger, was requested by Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru to support the new venture.
            As narrated by Mr Geithner, while the Planning Commission was first established in 1950, it really came into its own in the run up to the second Five-Year Plan in 1956. In this process, the issue arose of where capacity should be created for objective analysis to underpin the design of that Plan.
            After considerable discussion it was concluded that such capacity was best located outside Government in an independent, board-run organisation, rather than as part of the Government machinery. The basic argument was that an entity situated within Government would inexorably find itself drawn to support and rationalise Government policy, rather than provide disinterested advice. More controversially, it was also decided that the way to keep the proposed institution focused on practical problems was to make it dependent on contract research. Those discussions took place almost 60 years ago. India, the world and India’s position in the world are fundamentally altered from that era. It is entirely appropriate that the role and function of the Planning Commission should be under review, and it is encouraging that the prime minister has stimulated public debate on the subject.

            After considerable discussion it was concluded that such capacity was best located outside Government in an independent, board-run organisation, rather than as part of the Government machinery. The basic argument was that an entity situated within Government would inexorably find itself drawn to support and rationalise Government policy, rather than provide disinterested advice.

            From my perch here in the Netherlands, it has been easier for me to follow the debate in the press than to participate in live discussions. I have followed with interest the debate sponsored by the advocacy group CUTS, as well as recent columns by Shankar Acharya and C Rangarajan. From these sources and other press reports, it appears that a decision in principle has been taken to hive off many executive functions that over time had been assigned to the Planning Commission while strengthening its role as a central, influential and (ideally) objective policy commentator. While not perhaps impossible, it is certainly tricky for such a body to maintain its independence from the Government of the day, and much depends on the formal governance mechanisms and informal conventions that emerge.
            Some would argue that this is exactly the balancing act that the chief economic adviser (CEA) to Union Government has been required to perform these many years, often with distinction. But this only deepens the question of why a second such locus is needed, particularly as the CEA is supported, at least in theory, by the professional cadre of the Indian Economic Service. The design questions that need to be addressed, however, ought really to go deeper, and to articulate not just the kind of polity that we currently are, but also the kind of polity that we aspire to become in the coming decades: monolithic and centrally directed by a strong state; or diffuse, decentralised, federal and plural with knowledge a vital public good for ensuring coherent and coordinated action over a vast population and territory.
            Most observers would point to the United States as the society where policy institutions located outside Government are arguably more influential than in most other democracies. In my view, this vibrancy derives from four specific characteristics of that society. These are its presidential form of Government; the system of presidential appointments to civil service jobs (“the spoils system”); a high-quality university-research culture; and a philanthropic culture underpinned by a supportive tax system.
            The presidential form creates a need for aspiring presidential candidates to develop independent, informed, differentiated policy positions, while the spoils system promises power and influence to those scholars who back the right candidate.
            The spoils system also means that there is a need to house the losers when there is a change of administration, and it is easier to transit in and out of policy institutions than it is out of universities. The university-research culture raises the standard for all intellectual work in the society, and provides a benchmark of intellectual quality and accountability that filters across to the best of the policy institutions. Finally, at its heart the United States remains a revolutionary society born of distrust of central authority. As a result, public financial support to this intellectual infrastructure is provided indirectly through a liberal interpretation of non-profit status rather than through the direct patronage of contracts from Government. (2) In contrast with the United States, it is striking how few parliamentary systems have succeeded in building an ecosystem of successful and influential policy institutions.
            While Britain certainly is peppered with a range of economic and security policy institutions, I do not get the sense that they are central to Whitehalldeliberations although they influence public debate through the media. In Australia, think tanks are a relative rarity, with the Lowy Institute a pioneer, while in Japan (and in South Korea) think tanks are set up by ministries and led by trusted retirees. What guidance does this provide for the future of the Planning Commission? I am, of course, biased, but it would be a big pity if such a body supplanted rather than complemented the rich, if underfunded, spectrum of existing policy institutions in India, which is rare in Asia.
            The successor body should concentrate on three principal roles: agenda setting; synthesis of important research results in chosen areas from whatever sources; and convening power to stimulate public and political discussion on key long-term issues.
            In brief, it should aim to bring knowledge back into the policy process, rebutting the late Raj Krishna’s charge that India is (or was) knowledge-proof. Given my current location in the Shell scenarios group, I would also urge that such a dialogue could productively take place using the tools of scenario thinking rather than just modelling and forecasting.
            (The writer is chief economist, Royal Dutch Shell. These views are his own.)
            (1.) Father of Timothy Geithner, the former United States Treasury secretary in the Barack Obama administration
            (2.) The federal Government is an important supporter of university research in the United States, but has developed elaborate and largely successful systems of peer review by academics to govern the award of such grants.

            -BS

            loading...
            Share197Tweet123Share49
            • Trending
            • Comments
            • Latest

            Babu of delhi

            January 12, 2017
            Kin seek Centre’s help to bring back mortal remains of two Telangana men killed in Riyadh accident

            Kin seek Centre’s help to bring back mortal remains of two Telangana men killed in Riyadh accident

            July 25, 2019
            Aryan Khan Dances His Way To The Top Of Trends With Mystery Friend

            Aryan Khan Dances His Way To The Top Of Trends With Mystery Friend

            July 26, 2019
            NAked1

            ‘Naked’ Truth of Damodar Valley Project

            1
            ISRO

            ISRO scripts history, Launches 104 satellites in one go

            1
            V-Shanmuganathan

            Meghalaya Governor Resigns over Harassment Allegation.

            1
            Mum couple held in Kolkata for smuggling gold

            Mum couple held in Kolkata for smuggling gold

            December 11, 2019
            Thane: Chemicals’ discharge into drain irks all

            Thane: Chemicals’ discharge into drain irks all

            December 11, 2019
            After Months Of Deadlock, Israel Heads To Third Election In A Year

            After Months Of Deadlock, Israel Heads To Third Election In A Year

            December 11, 2019
            • Nation
            • World
            • Economy
            • Sports
            • Entertainment
            • Lifestyle
            • Tech
            Powered By FiHD

            Copyright © 2019 ChauthiDuniya.

            No Result
            View All Result
            • Home
            • News
              • World
              • Science
            • Entertainment
              • Sports
            • Tech
            • Lifestyle
              • Health

            Copyright © 2019 ChauthiDuniya.